Tuesday, July 14, 2009

A Load of B.S.

"B.S.," of course, stands for "BookScan," as in Nielsen BookScan. BookScan is the best and worst thing that's ever happened to you. Why?

Well, a quick history. The Nielsen company enjoyed considerable success throughout the 1990s with Nielsen SoundScan, a service that aggregated and reported POS (point-of-sale, i.e. scanned through the register) data from a wide variety of retailers. For the first time, it was possible for the industry to really see how it was doing; sales from thousands of record labels could be tracked on a weekly basis at dozens of major stores. So, in 2001, Nielsen figured they'd try their hand at books.

There's a .pdf you can download from the BookScan site to tell you exactly which retailers provide POS data to Nielsen, but for your convenience, I've listed them below:

B. Dalton • Barbara's Bookstores • Barnes & Noble • Books-A-Million • Borders • Deseret Book Co • Follett Stores • Hastings • Hudson Group • Independents • Walden Books (owned by Borders)

Discount & Others
Amazon.com • B&N.com • BooksAMillion.com • Borders.com • Buy.com • CatholicCompany.com • CNI • CEORead.com • Cornerstone • Costco • Fatbrain.com • K-Mart • NBC.com • One World Enterprises • Powells.com • Stretch the Skies • Target

Non-Traditional (New for 2008)
H.E.B. • Kroger • Stop & Shop • Shopko • Toys "R" Us • Babies "R" Us • Starbucks

What's as important as the retailers listed here, however, is the retailers that aren't; specifically, Wal-Mart, Sam's Club, and BJ's Wholesale Club. Because they (and several other, much smaller) outlets don't report their sales figures to BookScan, BookScan's numbers aren't complete. As I've said before, on a good day, they probably capture only about 75% of the overall marketplace.

The Good

For the most part, BookScan generates an accurate picture of any given title's overall sales. Moreover, it's the only tool the publisher has to analyze sales of books that aren't theirs, so even if it weren't as accurate as it is, it's still all they've got. (Publishing houses do solicit POS data from their accounts, so they have separate, often more accurate sales figures for their own titles.) If Chester A. Author published his first book with House A and is now at House B for his second, House B will use BookScan to analyze sales for his first book. These numbers, combined with comp title information, will factor significantly into the initial buys for his second book. The theory goes that the aggregate POS data will provide an accurate picture of previous sales, thus providing the foundation for reasonable expectations on future sales.

The Bad

You'll notice I said "for the most part." Since major retailers like Wal-Mart don't report to BookScan, a title that rocked out at said major retailers but failed to perform on-line or in the national chains (it's rare, but it happens) will have artificially depressed sales figures. (If you're the author of this unfortunate book, you'll be depressed as well. Ba-dum chh.) Seriously, though, if your book sold 10,000 copies, but 5,000 were at Wal-Mart, Sam's Club, and BJ's, your BookScan numbers will be off by a whopping 100%.

The Ugly

As agent Andrew Zack notes in his own post about BookScan, there are some publishers who, despite knowing full well that BookScan only provides a partial picture of overall POS transactions, treat it as if it were the be-all and end-all of book sales. Not only that, but in one case, BookScan reported numbers as low as ten percent of a book's actual sales, and editors at the (undisclosed) house had to be convinced of this by the author's actual royalty statements. (Zack doesn't say what said publisher actually decided concerning his client's new book, although he does follow up on his initial post here and here.) And, in case you were wondering, BookScan never changes its numbers—ever—so you can't complain to the Men Upstairs to adjust your reported sales if you think they're wrong.

Which brings us to the question: What can you do if you think you're getting B.S.ed by B.S.?

First, do your homework. As noted in Alan Rinzler's excellent primer on BookScan, you can subscribe to Nielsen's service for $5,000 per year (pricey!) or just $85 per year if you only want to track a single ISBN. Know thy sales. Like Alan says in his post, an author's BookScan numbers are like a credit rating, and are just as (if not more) important.

If you think there's a problem, approach your agent. Have him or her go over your royalty statements with you. This can help you figure out whether there's a major discrepancy between the publisher's numbers (which will be more accurate) and BookScan's.

If you and your agent believe there's a serious problem, contact your publisher. Let them know you're afraid artificially low sales reports from BookScan may impact sales on your future books. If possible, ask them to review their sales numbers and let you know if there's a problem. (The publishing house I work with maintains huge Excel files of market share data, which is beginning to include data from previously reticent retailers like Wal-Mart.)

Of course, this all only applies to non-debut authors; for those of you whose next book will be your first, your numbers may depend in large part on the BookScan numbers for your comp title, which you can't really control. If that's the case, just keep on keepin' on—promote yourself, promote your book, and do whatever you can to get your name and your story out there.


  1. Hey! I popped over from Nathan's blog! Brilliant post; I learned a lot.

  2. New reader, also over from Nathan's blog. Good info. I'll be sharing this with my blog readers.

  3. As always, great post! I'm so glad you started this blog!

  4. Glad you started the blog! It's shaping up to be extremely helpful - great post!

  5. Awesome post. My writing teacher touched on BookScan in class; you added to my knowledge bank. Most informative. :)

  6. Here via Nathan B and Moonrat, and just wanted to say, YAY FOR YOU! Thanks for demystifying this end of things. :)

  7. I see "Independents" listed as reporting to BookScan, but I think I read somewhere else (Alan Rinzler's article, maybe?) that BookScan only only captures SOME of those stores. How do you know if an Indie store reports to BookScan or not?

    ...Just checked. Alan Rinzler says that BookScan tracks sales from "450 independent bookstores (extrapolated from 1700 total.)" What does that mean?

    THANK YOU! This is all very helpful stuff.

  8. I'm a Berkley/Penguin novelist and followed you from Nathan's blog. Just subscribed. What a great blog idea. If you ever need a post or anything else from a midlist writer, let me know...I'd be happy to pitch in.

  9. Nathan and Moonie sent me, too :). Awesome blog! Thank you so much for this info, and for telling it like it is!

  10. Very useful information. Thanks!

  11. Clicked through from Janet Reid. Thanks for all that info!

  12. Geez, yet another crazy ass thing to mess with the minds of authors. Obviously, getting published is not the end of the story. Not even close.

    Hey, everyone is linking to you today. Congrats! Now the pressure's on. Har har.

    Post idea for you: I have a friend (seriously, it's a friend and not me) who has self published several educational books and games. He sells them at B&N and indie book stores via local sales reps throughout the country. He seems to get by (still has full time teaching job) with small sales in many many stores. Any opinion about taking on self pubbed stuff like that? Would be interesting to hear from your POV.

  13. So happy you decided to start the blog (and with such a bang!) Congrats on all the links you're getting today from the big guys.

    One of my favorite features on your blog is the list of blogs on the right -- specifically the fact that they're updated. Now I can come here first and know whether or not to check out some of my other favorites yet or not.

    Thanks to this blog, I guess I'll forgive you the fact that Nathan chose your post over mine :)

  14. Thanks for the great post. Very informative!

    I'm wondering about other countries. In Canada, Chapters/Indigo is our big chain and I buy most of my books through them. How do publishers factor in sales from outside of the States?

  15. so glad you started your blog! and you've got, um, well, do we need to say the # of followers? yay! have fun.

  16. Hi Jennie—

    That sounds great. If I'm not in touch in a couple of weeks, please re-comment to remind me.

  17. Hi Vacuum Queen & Anon @ 6:32—

    Great ideas. I'll try and work them in this coming week.

  18. Found this through Janet Reid. Brilliant blog! Looking forward to more!

  19. Late to comment but just wanted to say thanks for the great information. In my past life I was a media buyer, this sounds so familiar...ratings/rankings/numbers aren't always how they appear. I just didn't know it also applied to books sales so thanks for the education!

    Great blog, btw.

  20. Great work. Truly speaking I never seen a blog like that. Absolutely superb work. Good luck. Thanks for such an informative post.
    herbal incense

  21. I just wanted to add a comment to mention thanks for your post. This post is really interesting and quite helpful for us. Keep sharing.
    diablo incense

  22. Perfect Blog. Very impressive. Continue doing the great job! Thanks

    Buy Herbal Incense

  23. This comment has been removed by the author.